Best of Ontario - As chosen by you! Hidden Gems

Best Pumpkin Pie in Ontario – As chosen by you!

Photo via Moo Milk BarPhoto from Moo Milk Bar.

When there is a crispness in the air and the leaves start to change, it’s time to celebrate one of our favourite harvest treats in Ontario: pumpkin pie! We asked you where to find the best pumpkin pie and here’s a sample of what you told us.

Williamsford Pie Company – Williamsford, Ontario
Submitted by Jane P.

Wholesome and delicious! Williamsford Pie Company is a labour of love for owner Laura Snider. Raised on a family farm, Laura brings the farm fresh flavour to her bakery using only fresh ingredients. Their yummy pumpkin pie is available by special order and is a favourite with cottagers and locals.

williamsford pie company

Stone Crock Bakery – St. Jacobs, Ontario
Submitted by Tara G. and Sindy S.

St. Jacob’s is renowned for Canada’s largest year round Farmers Market and the charming Village of St Jacobs. The Stone Crock Bakery uses family recipes to create delicious treats, including their pumpkin pie.

St. Jacobs in the morning 3

Whittamore’s Farm – Markham, Ontario
Submitted by Daniel W.

Whittamore’s is well known for the family fun offered year round, from games to hayrides to meeting the farm animals. Their farm shop is a great bonus, with fresh produce seasonally and home baked pies and tarts.

Whittamore's Farm

Burnham Family Farm Market – Coboug, Ontario
Submitted by Debbie B.

This family farm dates back to the 1840s – so you know the family pumpkin pie recipe is tried and tested!

Burnham Family Farm Market

Andrew’s Scenic Acres – Milton, Ontario
Submitted by Carol V. and Odete R.

Whether you head to the farm to pick up a pie, or have come across Andrew’s Scenic Acres at a farmer’s market, the fact is well known that their pies are some of the best you can get.

Autumn's Haul

Bonus: Get your fill of pumpkin pie along the Halton Pumpkin Trail! Runs through October 2013.

Have a favourite pumpkin pie of your own? Add it to the comments below!

3 replies on “Best Pumpkin Pie in Ontario – As chosen by you!”

Williamsford Pie Company is amazing. Try to drive by without stopping. It is an old fashioned building, everything is home made, the coffee is great and the service is amazing and friendly. So many different varieties of pies..but get there early as she sells out fast at Easter, Thanksgiving and Christmas. Even local restaurants order these pies.

If you find yourself in the Peterborough area, I would highly recommend Enticing Cakes – their pumpkin pie is the bomb!! We even treat ourselves to it in the off season by special order.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *